Review: Batman Vol. 1 – I Am Gotham (DC Rebirth) by Tom King & David Finch

batmanThe whole purpose of DC’s ongoing ‘Rebirth’ initiative is to relaunch the publisher’s well-loved core characters in their most iconic forms. In other words, make them accessible to new readers, but throw in some bones for the long-time fans, too. Tom King and David Finch’s first volume of their Batman run achieves this. It’s a fun, action-packed story-arc, which introduces two new superheroes into the lore, and leaves plenty of page space for Finch to showcase his artistic skill. It’s a fun romp; but it’s not much more than that. Which is enough, for some; but for readers such as myself, who dip in and out of mainstream comics, there’s not quite enough here to warrant a return for the second volume.

When a couple of masked metahumans with the powers of Superman arrive in Gotham City, Batman thinks they have the potential to be the kind of heroes he won’t ever be: he is only human, after all. With their super powers and impervious dedication to the protection of the city from its own sordid underbelly, Gotham and Gotham Girl are precisely the kind of guardians who can protect Gotham for decades to come. That is, until their perceptions are twisted by one of Batman’s villains, and suddenly Gotham’s most powerful heroes become a force for evil, and the Dark Knight becomes their target for termination.

Tom King is currently penning one of my favourite comic series, The Sheriff of Babylon, but his Batman run lacks the punch of that creator-owned series. It’s not that his writing here is of an inferior quality; just that, by necessity, and the fact this is a mainstream superhero comic book, it has been stripped of much of its nuance. His pairing with David Finch seems wasted, too; while the artist excels at the big moments, and the action-packed pages are wonderful to behold, the quieter moments lack any sort of pop and emotional gravitas.

I Am Gotham is a solid superhero yarn, which sets the board for King and Finch’s run on the title. I’ve read better superhero comics, and I’ve read worse. It is stuck in that annoying middle ground, where there’s not much to say about it, one way or the other. It’s a book I read, enjoyed, and won’t remember.

ISBN: 9781401267773
Format: Paperback  (252mm x 168mm x 15mm)
Imprint: DC Comics
Publisher: DC Comics
Publish Date: 24-Jan-2017
Country of Publication: United States

Review: The Sheriff of Babylon, Vol. 1: Bang. Bang. Bang. by Tom King King & Mitch Gerads


Babylon02.jpgThe Sheriff of Babylon is far more than the sum of its parts. It would be easy to label it as a crime story set in post-9/11 Middle East — and you wouldn’t be wrong, because at a fundamental level, that’s what it is: a whodunit set in unfamiliar terrain — but its pointed political subtext, and its creators’ willingness to explore wider issues, makes The Sheriff of Babylon a far more provocative tale.

In post-Saddam Baghdad, Iraq’s capital city has been devastated, and is without a police force to keep its citizens safe. Former Florida police officer Chris Henry is now a US military consultant, and has been assigned to train the city’s future law enforcement personnel. But when one of his trainees is found dead, Henry is forced to take the mantle of investigator, and partners with Nassir — a former Baghdad detective — to unravel the mystery. Naturally it’s not quite as cut-and-dry as that. Nassir has his own secrets; the dead American soldiers in his basement is merely the exclamation on his troubles — and Henry’s sometime lover, Sofia — an American-born Iraqi — is convening with disparate factions to seize control over her country.

The Sheriff of Babylon is appropriately gritty and layered with authenticity thanks to writer Tom King’s experience in the CIA. Together with artist Mitch Gerads, they perfectly encapsulate the sense of a city, and entire nation, perched on the abyss. Everyone – from the civilians to the military personnel – are paranoid, and cognizant that they are a hair trigger’s moment from complete capitulation and anarchy. Chris Henry is a fabulous protagonist – as determined to uncover the truth as he is reluctant to shake too many trees – and King’s aversion to cluttered caption boxes means readers get to know the character exclusively through his dialogue and actions. It’s nice to not have his every thought and inclination spelled out – nuance is increasingly rare in comics, and it’s even rarer for creators to not baby their readers with voluminous explication.

King and Gerads have created an important work that conveys the culture clashes and inner-workings of post-Saddam Iraq. But just as it highlights the cultural differences, it underlines the kinship that unites all humans, regardless of race, ethnicity, or place of birth. Nothing is black and white in this world, and The Sheriff of Babylon is not afraid to expose the grays. This first volume concludes with plot threads left dangling, and like any great season finale, ends with a deserving (and devastating) cliffhanger that’ll leave readers emotionally drained, and desperate for the next installment. I’d say this is as good as comics get, but I wouldn’t put it past this creative team to one-up themselves in the next volume . . . which can’t come soon enough, as far as I’m concerned.

ISBN: 9781401264666
Format: Paperback
Pages: 144
Imprint: DC Comics
Publisher: DC Comics
Publish Date: 27-Jul-2016
Country of Publication: United States